PEP Screening Guide

§ 5.5

PEP red flags: what FATF's guidance says

Published

FATF publishes a set of PEP red flags, from hidden ownership to odd account use. What each one means, and what the guidance says to do when one appears.

What a PEP red flag actually is

A PEP red flag is a warning sign, not proof. FATF's guidance is plain on this. Its rules aim to prevent crime, not punish it. They do not brand PEPs as criminals.

The red flags are not a checklist either. FATF says its list is not complete. It adds to the usual money laundering red flags. A broader set sits in Annex 1 of the guidance.

One flag alone is rarely enough. FATF says matching one red flag may only raise risk, and several may be needed to create suspicion.

Identity and ownership red flags

The first group of PEP red flags is about who is really behind the account.

FATF says PEPs may try to hide who they are so they are not caught. Corrupt PEPs often hide behind legal entities. That way they enter the financial system without being spotted.

Two ownership patterns stand out. FATF lists using corporate vehicles to hide the beneficial owner as a red flag. It also lists using family members or close associates as legal owner. FATF says close associates and family members of PEPs must still be treated as PEPs. FATF says they might never be listed in any database.

FATF adds one firm rule here. FATF's guidance says verification of a beneficial owner believed to be a PEP is mandatory in any case.

Source of wealth and behaviour red flags

The next group is about how the customer explains their money.

FATF says a PEP may seem uneasy when asked where their wealth or funds come from. It says a PEP who cannot or will not give a believable reason is a red flag. The reason may be for opening an account or for a deal. Not offering details of wealth could also be a red flag.

Then there is the money itself. Activity may not fit what the PEP's known source of wealth can explain. FATF says that gap should prompt a further look, and soon.

FATF also warns against judging by what a firm expects. Firms should weigh what a PEP's wealth can reasonably explain, not what they think it should be. FATF says a risk assessment that rests on what is expected does not comply with Recommendation 12. The test is wealth that can be explained.

FATF says what a customer tells a firm may not match other sources. That gap could point to money laundering. FATF says it should never be ignored.

Account and transaction red flags

Some flags show up in the account itself. FATF says a red flag is when a PEP uses many bank accounts for no clear reason. Another is when personal and business money flows are hard to tell apart.

FATF also says higher risk products add to the risk when PEPs use them. A connection with a high risk industry may raise the risk of doing business with a PEP too.

Relationship and history red flags

The past can carry warnings. FATF says multiple STRs submitted on a PEP are a red flag. So is a case where other financial firms have ended their dealings with the PEP.

Power matters as well. FATF says a PEP with a lot of power over state assets and funds is a possible red flag.

Country red flags

Where the PEP is from counts. FATF names several country red flags:

  • A PEP from a country that credible sources say has a high risk of corruption
  • A PEP from a country with poor and opaque government, where leaders are hard to hold to account
  • A foreign or domestic PEP from a higher risk country
  • PEPs from countries with high levels of organised crime
  • PEPs from countries that rely on selling illegal goods such as drugs abroad
  • PEPs from countries ruled by one person who holds all the power
  • PEPs from countries that have not signed or put in place treaties against corruption
  • PEPs from countries whose economy rests on just a few exports

FATF adds one more. Extra risk arises when a PEP from a higher risk country could influence fixes to AML and CFT shortcomings.

What FATF's guidance says to do when a red flag appears

A red flag starts work, it does not end it. FATF says the assessment decides what happens next. The firm keeps the relationship, ends it, or reports the suspect deals. FATF's guidance says a financial institution suspecting money laundering should file an STR to the financial intelligence unit.

Ending the relationship is not a given. FATF says the Recommendations do not force a firm to drop a PEP it suspects. FATF also says keeping up a business tie with a PEP it suspects may lead to criminal liability.

Refusing a PEP outright is its own problem. FATF says turning a client away just for being a PEP goes against Recommendation 12.

In the US, the Agencies' 2020 joint statement on PEPs takes its own approach. The Agencies say a PEP is not high risk just because of the title. The due diligence should match the risk of the relationship. The CDD rule does not require banks to have extra due diligence steps for PEP customers. It does not require banks to screen for PEPs either. The Agencies do remind banks to spot and report suspicious activity. That includes money that may come from corruption.

Where red flags sit in the wider PEP process

Red flags feed a risk assessment, they do not replace it. FATF says a list cannot be the only source. It also does not override a risk assessment of the client. A name not appearing in a database does not mean the client is not a PEP.

Screening has limits, which is why PEP screening and PEP list search are only the start. FATF says finding out a customer is a PEP does not end the due diligence. Further ongoing due diligence still applies. That ongoing work is covered in enhanced due diligence for PEPs.

FATF also warns against treating detection as a form to fill in. FATF says finding PEPs should not turn into ticking boxes. The key is to handle the risks of higher risk PEPs.

Sources