§ 2.2
OFAC Violations and Penalties
- Published
A walk through OFAC's published enforcement framework, from the Prepenalty Notice to the final decision, and the factors that set the penalty amount.
What counts as an OFAC violation and who OFAC can act against
OFAC's FAQ says violations of OFAC-administered sanctions programs may result in civil and, in some cases, criminal penalties. OFAC's guidelines define a Subject Person as an individual or entity subject to any sanctions program OFAC administers or enforces. A person or a company can both be in the frame. OFAC's framework says it will consider using its enforcement authorities against individuals as well as violating entities.
To understand what the rules ask of you before any breach, see OFAC requirements.
The range of enforcement responses
Not every case ends in a fine. OFAC's guidelines list several responses.
A case may end with no action. That can happen if there is not enough proof that a violation took place. That call is final unless OFAC later learns of new related violations or new facts.
OFAC may also send a cautionary letter. OFAC's guidelines say the letter ends the case. But it is not a final finding that a violation took place.
OFAC may issue a Finding of Violation when a civil fine is not the best fit. It gives the Subject Person a chance to reply before it becomes final.
OFAC's guidelines say it may impose a civil monetary penalty when conduct warrants a monetary penalty. A civil fine means OFAC has made a final call that a violation took place.
OFAC may also send a case to law enforcement for criminal charges. A case sent for criminal review can still draw an OFAC fine or other action. OFAC may also hold back, deny, suspend, change, or revoke licenses. OFAC may also order a Subject Person to cease and desist from conduct its sanctions programs ban.
How OFAC decides a case is egregious
OFAC uses general factors to pick its action and the size of any civil fine. Two of them are willfulness and awareness.
OFAC gives substantial weight to willfulness and awareness of conduct when deciding whether a case is egregious. OFAC acts more strongly when the conduct is willful. The same goes when the person meant to break the law. It also acts more strongly when a person knew more about the conduct behind an apparent violation. OFAC also weighs two things. Did the person try to hide the conduct to mislead OFAC or another regulator? Was the violation part of a pattern, or a one-off?
OFAC also weighs the harm the conduct did, or could have done, to the goals of a sanctions program. The Director or Deputy Director decides whether a case is egregious.
The penalty amounts OFAC publishes
OFAC's FAQ says civil penalties vary by sanctions program and OFAC must adjust civil monetary penalty amounts annually. The current amounts are in Appendix A to 31 CFR part 501. That is the Economic Sanctions Enforcement Guidelines.
In egregious cases, the base penalty is set from the cap in the law. OFAC's guidelines state the IEEPA maximum civil penalty is the greater of $377,700 or twice the underlying transaction value. The Trading with the Enemy Act maximum civil penalty is $111,308. Take an egregious case that was self-disclosed. Its base penalty is half the cap set by law. In an egregious case that was not self-disclosed, the base penalty is the full cap. The fine OFAC proposes will not go over the cap that applies.
OFAC's FAQ says a list of select OFAC enforcement actions, organized by year, is on the Civil Penalties and Enforcement Information page.
Mitigating factors
Voluntary self-disclosure is one of them. OFAC's FAQ says OFAC considers voluntary self-disclosure a mitigating factor that may reduce the base amount of a civil penalty. It may also give a better chance of avoiding a fine.
A voluntary self-disclosure must come with a report. The report must be full enough to show the whole violation. Sometimes the first notice comes without the full report. OFAC then usually expects the report within 180 days. Some acts do not count as a voluntary self-disclosure. Answering a subpoena is one. Filing a license request with OFAC is another.
OFAC's penalty rules say it may consider the existence, nature, and adequacy of a person's risk-based OFAC compliance program. It may also weigh the fixes a person made after the violation. And it may weigh how much the person helped OFAC. OFAC's guidelines say that in a self-disclosure case, working with OFAC can cut the fine further. OFAC will also note that help in public.
A first violation usually cuts the base penalty by up to 25 percent. OFAC's guidelines define a first violation using the five years before the date of the transaction. It counts as a first violation if no penalty notice or Finding of Violation came in those five years. OFAC's penalty rules say it will only consider sanctions history for the five years before the transaction at issue.
OFAC's guidelines say refusing to enter a tolling agreement will not be considered an aggravating factor. OFAC looks at the whole picture so the response fits the violation.
The penalty process step by step
OFAC's Director notifies a suspected violator of an alleged violation by issuing a Prepenalty Notice. It says what the alleged violation is. It also gives the civil fine OFAC proposes. A Prepenalty Notice may be sent whether or not some other agency has acted on the matter.
A respondent who admits a violation may offer information on why a monetary penalty should not be imposed or should be less. A written reply may lead to a lower fine. That holds when there are no aggravating factors. A respondent who does not reply within the 60-day period may face a Penalty Notice.
OFAC's Director issues a Penalty Notice absent a settlement agreement or a finding that no violation occurred. A Penalty Notice means OFAC has made a final call that a violation occurred. It cannot exceed the Prepenalty Notice amount by more than 10 percent. This is true unless a revised Prepenalty Notice is sent.
A respondent may ask for an administrative hearing. This is only allowed after a Penalty Notice is sent. OFAC's Director may issue an Order Instituting Proceedings and refer the matter to an Administrative Law Judge. The judge's ruling is final unless a Secretary's designee reviews it. When there is a review, a Secretary's designee makes the Department's final call. A respondent may seek judicial review of the Department's final decision.
The Director may drop the case based on what the respondent shows. The Director or a respondent may offer to settle at any point in the process. OFAC's guidelines say a settlement is not a final finding that the law was broken. OFAC may condition settlement negotiations on a tolling agreement with respect to the statute of limitations.
OFAC's rules say the Director must notify a respondent in writing if he finds no violation or no penalty is warranted. Any final order of the Department shall be made public. OFAC shall make public the name and address of an entity in a civil penalties proceeding. The name of an individual violator will not be made public.
Reporting failures carry their own penalties
OFAC sets its own penalties for late reports and for not giving information. OFAC's guidelines say failing to furnish information under 31 CFR 501.602 may result in a penalty of up to $29,150. Failing to give information may be a continuing violation. A fine may be added for each month it goes on. A required report that is late may bring a civil fine of up to $3,550. That is if it is filed within the first 30 days. An overdue blocked assets report may add a fine of $1,422 for every 30 days. This may go on for up to 10 years.
OFAC's FAQ says knowingly making materially false statements in a submission to OFAC may result in criminal penalties.
Where a compliance program fits in
OFAC may mitigate a civil monetary penalty based on the existence, nature, and adequacy of a sanctions compliance program under General Factor E. OFAC's framework says OFAC has found program weaknesses in many public enforcement actions since it issued its enforcement guidelines.
For how to build one, see OFAC compliance program. For more on economic sanctions and how OFAC runs them, see those pages.
OFAC's FAQ encourages anyone aware of possible violations to report them to OFAC through OFAC's Disclosure Portal. OFAC's FAQ says FinCEN maintains a whistleblower incentive program for violations of OFAC-administered sanctions and the Bank Secrecy Act.
Sources
- 31 CFR Part 501, Reporting, Procedures and Penalties Regulations (OFAC) (31 CFR 501) (31 CFR Part 501)
- FFIEC BSA/AML Office of Foreign Assets Control - Office of Foreign Assets Control (FFIEC) (OFAC) (FFIEC BSA/AML Examination Manual)
- Creator: Acrobat PDFMaker 17 for Word (OFAC) (A Framework for OFAC Compliance Commitments)
- | Office of Foreign Assets Control (OFAC's FAQ) (OFAC FAQ) (OFAC)
- | Office of Foreign Assets Control (OFAC's FAQ) (OFAC FAQ) (OFAC)