§ 1.3
How Sanctions Work: From Designation to Penalty
- Published
A plain-language walk through how sanctions work: what imposing them means, how blocking and rejecting differ, what licenses do, and how OFAC and OFSI penalize breaches.
Sanctions limit dealings with the countries, groups and people they target. This page walks through how the system works. It starts on the day a name goes on a list and ends on the day a penalty is issued. The main example is OFAC and the U.S. sanctions programs it runs. The page also compares the UK rules in OFSI's guidance. For the wider picture, see our guide to economic sanctions and the sanction definition itself. If a whole country is the target, read what are sanctions on a country. The different types of sanctions page covers the kinds of measures in use.
What imposing sanctions actually means
To impose sanctions is to make certain dealings against the law for the people the law covers. OFAC says its sanctions use blocking of assets and trade limits. These tools serve foreign policy and national security goals. OFAC says its sanctions can be either comprehensive or selective. OFAC's FAQ says some programs broadly prohibit activity involving certain regions, countries, or governments. OFAC's FAQ says others block the property of specific people and entities. The FFIEC manual says OFAC sanctions target foreign countries, regimes, terrorists, and drug traffickers. Many programs come from United Nations and other world mandates. They are shared by many states.
Who administers sanctions and against whom
OFAC administers a number of different sanctions programs. OFAC's FAQ says each program is based on its own foreign policy and national security goals. One target list is the SDN List. OFAC's FAQ says U.S. persons as a rule cannot deal with anyone on the SDN List. Property of SDNs in the United States, or held by U.S. persons, is blocked. OFAC's FAQ says SDNs are designated under the Trading With the Enemy Act and the International Emergency Economic Powers Act. Some programs are not tied to any country. Terrorists and drug traffickers named under them are SDNs too.
Blocking reaches beyond the named entry. OFAC's FAQ says an entity's property is blocked if the entity is owned 50 percent or more by a blocked person. Some programs go further. OFAC's FAQ says some sanctions programs block whole groups of persons. That holds even if they do not appear on the SDN List.
What blocking means in practice
OFAC's FAQ says blocking means freezing assets or other property and prohibits all transfers or dealings with it. The property stays put. OFAC's FAQ says title to blocked property stays with the blocked person, but its use needs OFAC authorization. Property here is broad. OFAC's FAQ says property includes financial instruments, real assets, and tangible and intangible assets. Its rules block all property a target has an interest in. That covers a stake held now, one held later, or one that hangs on some event.
OFAC itself does not hold the money. OFAC's FAQ says OFAC does not seize or hold blocked funds. The bank or firm holding them keeps them. OFAC's FAQ says blocked funds must go into an interest-bearing account. Only OFAC-authorized debits may be made from it. The funds must earn interest at a commercially reasonable rate.
Blocking versus rejecting a transaction
The two words sound alike but do different things. OFAC's FAQ says a transaction is rejected when it is prohibited but has no blockable interest, and is returned to the originator. Blocking freezes property. Rejecting sends a payment back. Sanctions forbid it, but no blocked person has a stake in the funds. OFAC's FAQ says a transaction must be rejected when sanctions prohibit it but no blocked person is involved. Not all OFAC programs involve blocking transactions.
Licenses: the exception mechanism
The bans come with doors out. OFAC's FAQ says an OFAC license is an authorization from OFAC. With one, a person may do deals that would otherwise be banned. There are two types. OFAC's FAQ says a general license covers certain types of deals and works on its own. No one needs to apply for a specific license. A specific license is a private document. OFAC issues it to one person or firm for one deal. OFAC's FAQ says a person may apply for a specific license when no general license or exemption covers a prohibited transaction. OFAC's FAQ says certain transactions involving personal communications, humanitarian donations, informational materials, and travel may be exempt.
A blocked customer can ask for the funds to be released. OFAC's FAQ says a customer whose funds are blocked has the right to apply for the unblocking and release of the funds. OFAC's FAQ says authorization from OFAC is required for U.S. financial institutions to release blocked property.
Reporting obligations that come with blocking
Blocking or rejecting starts a clock. OFAC's FAQ says blocking and reject reports must be sent to OFAC within 10 business days of the action. A report of blocked property is due each year by September 30. OFAC's FAQ says blocking and reject reports must contain a copy of the original transfer instructions.
What happens when sanctions are violated
OFAC's FAQ says violations of OFAC-administered sanctions programs may result in civil and, in some cases, criminal penalties. OFAC's Prepenalty Notice describes the alleged violation and includes a proposed civil penalty amount. OFAC's guidelines say the Director issues a Penalty Notice if there is no deal to settle. A Penalty Notice is a final OFAC finding that a breach took place. Some cases end with no fine at all. OFAC's guidelines say a probe may end with no action or a cautionary letter. When a civil penalty is not the best response, OFAC may issue a Finding of Violation.
How penalties are calculated
OFAC's FAQ says civil fines vary by program. The current amounts are in the Economic Sanctions Enforcement Guidelines. These are Appendix A to 31 CFR part 501. OFAC's guidelines state the IEEPA maximum civil penalty is the greater of $377,700 or twice the underlying transaction value. For cases under the Trading with the Enemy Act, the maximum civil penalty is $111,308.
The base amount then moves with the facts. OFAC's guidelines say a grave case that the firm reports itself sets the base fine at half the top amount in the law. If the firm did not report it, the base is the full top amount. OFAC's FAQ says telling OFAC about the breach yourself can lower the penalty. OFAC's guidelines say a first breach as a rule cuts the base fine by up to 25 percent. A first breach means no penalty notice or Finding of Violation in the five years before the deal. OFAC's penalty rules say it may also weigh the strength of a compliance program. It may weigh steps to fix the problem and help given to OFAC. It may also weigh if the conduct helped an aid effort.
How the UK system compares
OFSI's guidance sets out the UK rules. OFSI's guidance says asset freezing is the most common financial sanction. An asset freeze as a rule bars dealing with the frozen funds or assets of a designated person. As with OFAC, who owns them does not change. OFSI's guidance says an asset freeze does not change ownership of the frozen funds or economic resources. OFSI's guidance says the person who holds or controls frozen funds must freeze them at once.
OFSI's guidance says a breach may bring a criminal case or a money penalty. OFSI can set money penalties under the Policing and Crime Act 2017. OFSI's guidance says the top penalty may be 50% of the total breach or £1m, whichever is greater. OFSI's guidance says it cuts penalties especially in cases the firm reported to OFSI itself.
Where to check current sanctions
OFAC's FAQ says each program is detailed on the Sanctions Programs and Country Information page of its website. Programs may change often. To check a name, search the official lists. OFAC's page says using Sanctions List Search does not limit criminal or civil liability for acts taken in reliance on it. OFAC's FAQ says each sanctions program is unique. So the rules for that program confirm the right action for any given case.
Sources
- 31 CFR Part 501, Reporting, Procedures and Penalties Regulations (OFAC) (31 CFR 501) (31 CFR Part 501)
- FFIEC BSA/AML Office of Foreign Assets Control - Office of Foreign Assets Control (FFIEC) (OFAC) (FFIEC BSA/AML Examination Manual)
- | Office of Foreign Assets Control (OFAC's FAQ) (OFAC FAQ) (OFAC)
- | Office of Foreign Assets Control (OFAC's FAQ) (OFAC FAQ) (OFAC)
- | Office of Foreign Assets Control (OFAC's FAQ) (OFAC FAQ) (OFAC)
- | Office of Foreign Assets Control (OFAC's FAQ) (OFAC FAQ) (OFAC)
- | Office of Foreign Assets Control (OFAC's FAQ) (OFAC FAQ) (OFAC)
- | Office of Foreign Assets Control (OFAC's FAQ) (OFAC FAQ) (OFAC)
- | Office of Foreign Assets Control (OFAC's FAQ) (OFAC FAQ) (OFAC)
- | Office of Foreign Assets Control (OFAC's FAQ) (OFAC FAQ) (OFAC)
- | Office of Foreign Assets Control (OFAC's FAQ) (OFAC FAQ) (OFAC)
- | Office of Foreign Assets Control (OFAC's FAQ) (OFAC FAQ) (OFAC)
- Sanctions Programs and Country Information | Office of Foreign Assets Control (OFAC)
- Sanctions List Search (OFAC) (OFAC's Sanctions List Search)
- UK financial sanctions general guidance - GOV.UK (OFSI) (UK) (Office of Financial Sanctions Implementation)
- Consolidated Screening List (Consolidated Screening List) (CSL) (Department of Commerce) (trade.gov)